A Quarterly Management Scorecard for Tampa Bay Boards: 12 Things to Check
Twelve yes-or-no checks on money, compliance, property and people
Most boards review their management company once, when the contract comes up for renewal. By then a year of small frustrations has blurred together and nobody can say exactly what went well or badly. A short review every quarter gives the board facts instead of impressions.
The scorecard below has 12 items. Each can be answered yes or no in a few minutes at a board meeting. It works for homeowners' associations and condominiums across Pinellas, Pasco, Hillsborough, Manatee and Sarasota counties, and it applies whoever your manager is.
Money
- Financial statements arrived on schedule every month. The board should not have to ask for them.
- Every bank account was reconciled, and the reconciliations were included or available on request.
- The delinquency report was current, and each late account shows the last action taken and the next one planned.
- Spending against budget was explained. When a line ran over, the manager said why before the board asked.
Compliance
- Every meeting was noticed correctly and on time, with an agenda, and minutes followed.
- Records requests were answered within the legal deadline. That is 10 business days for a homeowners' association (section 720.303) and 10 working days for a condominium (section 718.111).
- The association website or portal holds the documents the law requires, if the community is large enough to need one: 100 or more parcels for an HOA, 25 or more units for a condominium.
- The board received a calendar of upcoming deadlines, such as the budget, annual meeting, financial report, insurance renewal and director education.
Property and people
- Site inspections happened as often as the contract says, and the board received a written report.
- Open work orders and vendor issues were tracked, with dates, so nothing sat unanswered.
- Owner calls and emails were answered within the time the firm committed to. If no response time was ever agreed, that is worth fixing first.
- The manager came to meetings prepared, with recommendations, not only a list of problems.
What Tampa Bay boards should add
Local conditions deserve their own lines. For older condominium buildings in Pinellas County, ask whether the manager is tracking the building's inspection and reserve study obligations and reporting on them. For communities with a master association and condominiums or neighborhoods inside it, ask whether each board is getting its own financials and its own calendar. For any coastal community, ask before June whether the storm plan and vendor list were updated.
How to read the result
Count the yes answers. Ten or more means the basics are being delivered. A no that repeats two quarters in a row is the one to raise in writing. Several repeated misses, especially in the money and compliance sections, tell the board it is time for a direct conversation about the contract.
Share the scorecard with your manager before you use it. A good firm welcomes it, because it shows the board what is being done well and removes guesswork about what the board expects. Our article on setting expectations for your management company covers that first conversation.
If the score does not improve
Put the gaps in writing, agree on dates and review again next quarter. If the same items are still open, the board has a documented reason to look at other options and a ready list of what to ask the next firm. Our guide on how to switch management companies in Florida explains the steps.
Take it to your next meeting: Download the one-page quarterly scorecard (PDF).
Frequently asked questions
How often should a board review its management company?
Quarterly works well. It is often enough to catch a pattern and short enough to fit into a regular board meeting.
Who should fill in the scorecard?
The whole board, together, at a meeting. One director's experience can differ from another's, and a shared answer is more reliable.
Should the manager see the results?
Yes. The purpose is better service. A manager cannot fix what the board has not said.
Talk with our team
If your board would like to see how we report on each of these 12 items for communities in the Tampa and St. Petersburg area, request a proposal.
This article is general information for association boards and is not legal advice. Consult the association's attorney about your governing documents and obligations.












